Why Understanding Doesn’t Stop Emotional Reactions

Most people who find their way here aren’t confused.

They understand themselves.
They can explain why they react the way they do.
They’ve read the books, tried therapy, built insight.

And yet the same reactions keep forming anyway.

This page explains why — and what has to change for those reactions to stop forming in the first place.

Portrait of Randel Porter seated at his desk in his office

The Part of the System Most Approaches Miss

Emotional reactions don’t begin with conscious thought.

They begin at a layer where incoming information is interpreted and assigned meaning — before awareness, reflection, or choice. And, paradoxically for us, the “interpretation instructions” were installed a long time ago - for most of us, before the age of 10!

This is what I call the detection layer.

Its job is not understanding.
Its job is speed:

Is this safe?
Is this threatening?
Do I need to prepare a response?

“By the time you’re thinking “Why did that affect me so strongly?”
your system has already answered those questions and the battleship has fired, either internally or externally.”

Why Insight Arrives Too Late

Most therapeutic and coaching approaches work downstream from detection.

They help you:

understand your history
make sense of your emotions (over and over and over again, lol)
communicate more clearly
and “process” your pain

That’s why people can:

have excellent insight
understand their patterns
agree they’re overreacting

…and still feel the same reactions fire again.

This is why emotional intelligence and self-awareness don't always translate to emotional regulation—they're operating at different layers.

Understanding isn’t missing. In fact, too much understanding can contribute to the problem.

Regardless, the understanding is arriving too late and it is strangely not to be found the next time conflict occurs.

Common Misunderstandings About Emotional Reactions

Misunderstanding 1: "I need better coping skills"

Coping skills manage reactions that have already formed. They don't prevent the detection error that triggers the reaction in the first place.

Misunderstanding 2: "This is just who I am"

Emotional patterns aren't fixed personality traits. They’ve happened for so long they may seem like it, but they’re actually detection errors—and detection can be corrected.

Misunderstanding 3: "If I could just stop thinking about it..."

Rumination is often a symptom of an underlying detection error, not the cause. People often ruminate about what something means, or what another person thinks of them, or how can they be treated this way. Trying to control thoughts doesn't address why the system flags the situation as threatening in the first place.

What’s Actually Happening When You “Overreact”

The sequence usually looks like this:

A situation occurs
Meaning (typically negative) is assigned automatically
Threat or safety is registered
Physiology shifts (tension, narrowing, urgency)
A response fires

For some people, conscious thought may arrive at this point — but only to observe or manage a reaction that's already in motion.

For most, conscious thought doesn't arrive at all. The system stays in a feedback loop: reaction triggers more reaction, tension fuels more tension, and the threat response intensifies without reflection or pause.

This is why conflicts escalate, why anger takes over, and how blame and score keeping get fueled.

The detection error didn’t just occur early — it also prevented awareness from ever catching up. The participants are now just along for the ride, hanging on for dear life.

This cycle can then become the norm. It’s textbook for couples in crisis.

Example

A partner says, "Can we talk later? I'm exhausted."

Detection error reads this as: "You're not important. You're being dismissed."

Immediate response: Tension, urgency, preparing defense.

For some people: Conscious thought notices: "I'm getting upset. This is disproportionate." But can't stop the reaction from escalating.

For others: No conscious thought arrives. The response intensifies: "You never want to talk. You always do this." The conversation becomes a fight before either person realizes what happened.

Later — sometimes hours later — they think: "Why did I react so strongly to that?"

The actual culpritThe system misread "Can we talk later?” as dismissal or even rejection. By the time awareness could arrive, the reaction was already running at full speed.

Why Managing the Reaction Rarely Resolves It

Coping strategies, regulation tools, and communication skills can be helpful.

But they’re designed to manage reactions — not prevent them from forming.

As long as situations continue to be misread as threatening,
the system will keep generating the same responses.

That’s why progress can feel temporary:

insight helps, briefly
tools work, sometimes
effort increases

…but the pattern returns.

What Changes When Detection Becomes Accurate

The sequence usually looks like this:

reactions quiet without effort
rumination loses momentum
conversations feel safe
internal tension ceases to generate instead of requiring management.

People often describe feeling less anxious, less reactive in relationships, and more emotionally stable—not because they're trying harder, but because the system has stopped generating false alarms.

Not because you learned to cope better —
but because the system stops responding to things that aren’t actually threatening.

The experience changes at the source. This is why shifts can happen quickly — you're not building a new skill. You're correcting a misread.

Close-up of concentric circular wooden discs with visible grain and nails on a white background.

Who This Tends to Help Most

This work tends to resonate with people who are:

thoughtful and self-aware
functional in most areas of life
frustrated that insight hasn’t resolved this pattern

This includes people struggling with anxiety that won't respond to CBT, relationship patterns that therapy hasn't resolved, or emotional reactions that seem disproportionate to the situation.

It applies whether the reaction shows up internallyor between two people.

What matters is the mechanism — not the category.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why doesn't understanding my emotions stop the reactions?

Understanding happens after the reaction has already formed. The detection layer assigns meaning and triggers responses before conscious thought arrives. This is why you can have excellent insight and still experience the same reactions.

How is this different from traditional therapy?

Most therapy works downstream from detection—helping you understand and manage reactions after they form. This work corrects the misread at the detection layer, so reactions stop forming in the first place.

Can emotional reactions really change quickly?

Yes, when the detection error is corrected. You're not building a new skill—you're correcting a misread. This is why shifts can happen within the first session for many people.

Will this work if I've already tried therapy?

Most people who work with me have tried therapy, sometimes for years. This addresses a different layer than traditional approaches—where the misread happens before awareness arrives.

What if I don't notice I'm overreacting until later?

That's common. For many people, conscious thought doesn't arrive during the reaction—only hours or days later. This work corrects the detection layer so the reaction doesn't fire in the first place, regardless of whether you notice it in the moment.

What happens in a typical session?

Sessions focus on identifying where the detection error occurs—the exact moment neutral information gets misread as threatening. Once that's corrected, reactions often quiet immediately.

Is this the same as cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT)?

No. CBT works with thoughts and beliefs after they form. This works at the detection layer—before thoughts, where incoming information is first interpreted.

How long does this typically take?

Pattern interruption often happens within the first several sessions. Many people notice shifts in the first session. The work is complete when reactions no longer form in response to previously triggering situations.

Home

Individual Work

Couples Work

FAQ

Contact